On the subject of tenting necessities, a very good sleeping bag is fairly excessive up on the record.
However, what sort of sleeping bag do you have to go for?
It principally comes right down to 2 selections – mummy vs rectangular sleeping bag. The way you sleep and the way you camp will largely decide which sort is best for you.
On this article, I’ll inform you every part that you must find out about each forms of sleeping luggage, the professionals and cons of every, and the way they evaluate to one another.
By the point you end studying, the reply will likely be clear as day.
Prepared? Let’s get began!
Mummy Vs Rectangular Sleeping Bag – In contrast
Nonetheless confused as to which is finest?
Let’s study extra about each forms of luggage after which we will do a deep dive on which is nice for what.
The Mummy Sleeping Bag
Mummy luggage are formed to suit the contours of your physique, so that they’re a tighter match than traditional, rectangular formed sleeping luggage.
However what does this really imply?
Initially, their mummy form is nice at retaining you heat. When you’re heading out on a winter tenting journey, a mummy sleeping bag is certainly the way in which to go.
They’re additionally smaller in dimension, which suggests they’re a extra compact and light-weight bag. Because of this, backpackers nearly all the time go for mummy formed sleeping luggage to save lots of on house and hold their load mild.
On the flipside, which means that you’ve received quite a bit much less room to maneuver round in a mummy formed sleeping bag. The restricted motion side is one thing which may hassle you, particularly if you happen to like to change positions in your sleep quite a bit.
Professionals:
- The tighter match retains you hotter in chilly climate
- A extra compact and light-weight sleeping bag
Cons:
- The tight match additionally means restricted motion
- Can’t double as a quilt, not like an oblong bag
The Rectangular Sleeping Bag
Rectangular sleeping luggage offer you loads of room to maneuver round, so tossers and turners can have at all of it night time lengthy.
However, that further room comes at a price.
Extra space contained in the sleeping bag makes heating that house up tougher. You’re extra more likely to have points with chilly spots and your physique warmth won’t be sufficient to maintain you heat in colder climate circumstances.
Additionally, these luggage are bulkier and infrequently weigh considerably greater than mummy luggage. For that cause, rectangular luggage are usually extra widespread amongst automotive tenting fanatics than they’re amongst backpackers.
What’s cool about any such sleeping bag although is that it additionally doubles as a quilt. Simply unzip all of it the way in which, and also you’ve received a big, sq. quilt to cowl your self with, or use as a picnic blanket.
This makes the oblong sleeping bag an incredible summer time bag – good for these sizzling nights once you don’t must be zipped in.
And right here’s one other neat characteristic that’s distinctive to rectangular sleeping luggage:
When you’ve received 2 rectangular luggage which are suitable, you’ll be able to zip them up collectively to create a big, double sleeping bag.
That is nice for once you’re going tenting along with your important different. I imply, let’s face it – it’s a way more intimate resolution than sleeping subsequent to one another in separate luggage.
Professionals:
- Extra space to maneuver round contained in the sleeping bag
- Can be utilized as a quilt when unzipped
- You may zip 2 of them collectively to create a double bag for two folks
Cons:
- Not as heat as a mummy bag
- Typically significantly heavier and bulkier than a mummy bag
Mummy Vs Rectangular – The Final Sleeping Bag Showdown
OK, so now that we’ve talked about mummy luggage and rectangular luggage, let’s check out them aspect by aspect, to see how they evaluate in numerous areas.
Heat
On the subject of heat, mummy formed sleeping luggage win arms down.
They’ve received much less house inside, so it’s simpler to warmth that house up and hold it heat.
That being stated, if you happen to’ve received an oblong sleeping bag you’ll be able to nonetheless keep heat in colder climate. Simply fill your sleeping bag with dry garments, in order that as a lot of the empty house is crammed up as doable. This can be a tremendous useful little trick that’ll hold you heat when issues get chilly.
In fact, a sleeping bag liner, and a very good sleeping pad with the suitable temperature ranking may also do wonders in the case of staying heat, whichever form you select.
The winner: mummy formed sleeping luggage
Consolation
Within the consolation division, rectangular luggage take the cake.
The additional room they provide means your motion isn’t restricted like it’s in a mummy bag.
This implies you’re free to maneuver your legs and arms round. So, you’ll be able to sleep in whichever place you’re feeling like, and which positions as typically as you’re feeling like.
The winner: rectangular sleeping luggage
Portability
Attributable to their smaller dimension, mummy formed sleeping luggage are each lighter and extra compact than rectangular luggage. That makes them a lot simpler to hold round.
Mummy luggage are a favourite amongst backpackers for that reason exactly.
The winner: mummy formed sleeping luggage
Versatility
A mummy bag can solely actually be utilized in a method. An oblong bag, however, can be utilized in just a few alternative ways.
You may unzip it and use it as a big quilt for a number of folks. Or, you’ll be able to zip it along with one other rectangular bag, creating a big, double sleeping bag for 2 folks.
The winner: rectangular sleeping luggage
Affordability
When you’re tenting on a finances, you might need to consider affordability when making your choice.
Usually talking, the most costly sleeping luggage in the marketplace are mummy luggage. Nevertheless, you could find mummy luggage which are across the similar worth as some rectangular luggage.
So, whichever type you determine on, simply ensure you choose a sleeping bag with a very good price-performance ratio.
The winner: rectangular sleeping luggage
The Ultimate Verdict
So, as you’ll be able to see, each mummy luggage and rectangular luggage have their strengths and weaknesses, and it’s inconceivable to declare one clear winner. On the finish of the day, the sleeping bag form you select will come right down to your personal private wants and priorities.
Mainly, if you happen to’re a backpacker, or anyone going tenting in chilly climate and also you want a winter sleeping bag, you’ll most likely be higher off going for a mummy formed bag.
However, if you happen to like a little bit of wiggle room, and also you’re solely going summer time tenting, an oblong bag which you could unzip and use a blanket is the only option.
Both means, don’t neglect to verify the sleeping bag temperature ranking before you purchase. Make sure you go for a bag that may hold you heat in barely colder climate than you anticipate to come across in your tenting journeys.
Whichever kind of bag you determine on, make sure to do your analysis and skim opinions, like our Out of doors Vitals sleeping bag overview, to ensure you discover an superior sleeping bag.
